According to Sandy Petersen:
Steve is an old friend of mine, and he did in fact help germinate the American Gothic idea (the name was his idea, for instance). Another pal of mine, Marc Hutchison, was involved from the start. Steve wrote up a treatment basing it largely on D&D...The PDF document, which you can download here, is short but fascinating, particularly since it was written in May 1977 and uses OD&D/Chainmail terminology in places (such as the fighting capability of the "Mycenean Thought Crafters" class). Reading through it, you can see a number of things that call to mind the lost version of psionics that Steve Marsh created that was later reworked for inclusion into Eldritch Wizardry. It's well worth taking a look at this if you have any interest in the development of the games and ideas of the hobby.
Only the first paragraph of that document relates to "American Gothic". The other material (characters classes) is unrelated. The whole document is pages from Marsh's Cupric Text zine (similar to an Alarums & Excursions submission) that contains the usual jumble of material. This has been causing confusion for years. See harami's long explanation here at the Acaeum:
ReplyDeleteAcaeum post
Thanks for that clarification. I think the confusion probably arises because of the accompanying "certificate of authenticity" claims that the document is associated with American Gothic.
ReplyDeleteRight on. Thanks, James. I've been delving into Chainmail myself lately and have found a lot of very cool things. Looking forward to a glimpse at primordial CoC!
ReplyDelete: )
Just reading that one paragraph I can tell somebody was smoking the wacky baccy when they were typing that up.
ReplyDeleteHere's the later (2009) Acaeum post where the Collector's Trove backpedals on the "Certificate of Authenticity" for this item:
ReplyDeleteAcaeum post
FYI, the owner of these Marsh papers has destroyed the "Certificate of Authenticity" to make sure this never gets sold again by someone who perhaps wants to misrepresent it.
ReplyDelete*loads-up file*
ReplyDelete...
*presses nose to screen and sniffs*
hummm...? (is it odd that I can smell the musty old paper and typewriter ink through the computer screen?)
Ah ha. I've puzzled over it for a few years and, now, a few astute posts later, I am edified. Thanks for the links!
ReplyDeleteWaaaaaay off topic, but how is Two Towers going? It was always my favorite.
ReplyDeleteWaaaaaay off topic, but how is Two Towers going?
ReplyDeleteJust fine. My daughter is still enjoying the nightly readings, so I'm continuing ahead with the second volume.