Last September, I asked the question "why do you think SF RPGs are less popular than fantasy RPGs?" Today, I'm going to go a step further and ask, "why do you think modern day RPGs are even less popular than science fiction ones?" For the purposes of this question, "modern day RPGs" includes any game whose setting is post-medieval and includes no clear magic or supernatural elements. Consequently, a game like Call of Cthulhu is excluded from the category, because of its supernatural element, even though it's set in the right time period.
For myself, I think modern day RPGs are a lot less appealing than either fantasy or science fiction because, when devoid of magic or other similar things, they feel too much like the real world and most gamers roleplay to get away from the real world, even for a little while. When I look back on my own gaming history, it's true that I have played a handful of no-magic modern day games with some devotion -- Gangbusters comes immediately to mind -- I never played them as much as I've played, say, Dungeons & Dragons or Traveller. And, much as highly as I continue to regard some of those modern day RPGs, I can't deny that my interest in picking them up again now is more limited than in playing more fantastical games.
Friday, April 8, 2011
Thursday, April 7, 2011
Ah, Well
Looks like I was completely off in my interpretation of that illustration by Jeff Dee from Expedition to the Barrier Peaks. If you take a look at the following image, also from the same module, you'll recognize many of the same party members from the previous piece, like the bare-legged female fighter, the cleric, and the wizard. Also among them is a fighter whose helmet has a plume.
It's not the greatest scan of the image, unfortunately, but I think it pretty well clinches the feathered helmet hypothesis as the correct one. Ah, well.
It's not the greatest scan of the image, unfortunately, but I think it pretty well clinches the feathered helmet hypothesis as the correct one. Ah, well.
Little Details
When I was scanning the image used in my "F is for Firearms" post, I noticed some details in a piece of artwork from Expedition to the Barrier Peaks that I hadn't before. Drawn by Jeff Dee, it depicts an intellect devourer stalking a group of adventurers as they explore the alien spacecraft from the module.
Go ahead and enlarge the picture. With luck, you'll be able to notice something I hadn't previously. Look at the head and sword hand of the fighter in the rear of the party. Is it just me or has Dee depicted that the intellect devourer using psionic domination to control the fighter, who's preparing to attack his comrades from the rear? If so, that's a subtle little detail of the sort I really enjoy finding in gaming artwork. If not, what is it that I'm seeing?
Go ahead and enlarge the picture. With luck, you'll be able to notice something I hadn't previously. Look at the head and sword hand of the fighter in the rear of the party. Is it just me or has Dee depicted that the intellect devourer using psionic domination to control the fighter, who's preparing to attack his comrades from the rear? If so, that's a subtle little detail of the sort I really enjoy finding in gaming artwork. If not, what is it that I'm seeing?
F is for Firearms
It is a widely accepted fact that level of knowledge and technological advancement in the world has fallen considerably since the heyday of the Thulian Empire, never mind Eldritch or Ancient times. A good example of this decline can be seen in the near-total absence of ranged firearms in the present day. These weapons were once widely produced and used by Eldritch and early Thulian soldiers. Indeed, on Areon, such weapons continue to be common among the Eld.The magical principles behind the operation of firearms is well understood, at least among magic-users. However, their manufacture is mostly forgotten, at least among anyone except the Red Elves. Poor copies of these weapons -- colloquially called "wands" -- can be manufactured by a handful of sorcerers but such copies lack the power and versatility of true firearms. For one, wands can only be successfully operated by someone already possessed of magical ability, whereas firearms function for anyone. For another, wands cannot be recharged; once their stored arcane energy is used up, the wand ceases to function permanently. A firearm, however, can be reused, provided one has access to batteries of the appropriate type (which are, unfortunately, even rarer than working firearms in this day and age).
Nowadays, firearms are rarely seen except among adventuring parties regularly delving into sites sealed since at least Thulian times or members of secret societies with ties to other worlds. Working firearms are much sought after by warlords and wizards alike and command high prices on the few occasions they are sold on the open market. The Despot of Adamas is reputed to have a sizable cache of firearms and other similar weaponry -- a testament to the city-state's founding as a Thulian military base.
Wednesday, April 6, 2011
E is for Elves
(What else?)
The term "elf" is used to describe those intelligent, humanoid beings who can claim descent from the inhabitants of Areon, the Eld. In the past, the Eld entered this world as conquerors. Their dominion was largely unchallenged for millennia, the first -- and perhaps only -- successful rebellion against their rule was led by the Hyperborean barbarians known as the Thulians. The Eldritch nobility retreated en masse back to the Red Planet in the face of the Thulian onslaught. Those Eld unable to return whence they came, in time, to be known as elves.
Though elves are, on average, shorter than Men, they display a wide diversity of sizes, which is in contrast to their Eldritch forebears, who are almost all small of stature. Physically, they are lithe and agile and tend to possess fair complexions and hair. Their faces are delicate and finely chiseled -- not unattractive by any means but nevertheless possessing an "alien" quality to them that many Men find disconcerting rather than alluring. Elven ears are slightly pointed.
The alien quality of elves is not limited to their appearance. Distant and haughty, they do not seem to possess emotions as Men do or, if they do, they are far less demonstrative about them. Because of their long lives -- immortal unless some mishap befalls them or they commit suicide out of boredom -- they are often slow to act, preferring to take weeks or even months to commit themselves to a course of action of any significance. Elves gently mock humans and even dwarves as "ephemerals," seeing them as impetuous and foolhardy children. Needless to say, this has not helped their reputation among Men, many of whom consider them little better than the Eld of old.
Like Men, Elves exist in two genders but they do not form pair bonds, let alone marry. Affection, love, and even lust appear to be unknown to them, despite tall tales and folk stories that tell of star-crossed romances between humans and elves. Consequently, there are no children among the elves, leading some to believe that they are a dying race unable to procreate. If this is so, one wonders how it is that their numbers have not dwindled to non-existence in the face of human prejudice in the years since the overthrow of the Eldritch Empire. It's popularly believed that elves kidnap human children and, through magic, make them their own, a belief that has done little to improve the lot of the race.
Elves are inherently magical. All members of the race possess the ability to cast spells, though their command of sorcery seems to be more limited than that of humans. This is true, even among the Eld, which likely explains why they have turned to demons to augment their power, a practice that, while uncommon, is not wholly unknown among the elves.
A minority of sages claim that many elven sites and structures are in fact older than those of Eldritch manufacture, arguing that it was not the elves who sprang from the Eld but the reverse. For their part, the elves have nothing to say on this matter, preferring to say as little as possible about their red-skinned relations. An even smaller minority of sages suggests that the elves may in fact be the descendants of the mysterious "Ancients" whose mighty works and artifacts predate even the Eldritch Empire, citing odd similarities between Ancient devices and those produced by the elves. Once again, the elves have little to say on the matter and few Men are willing to countenance the suggestion that the Ancients were anything but members of their own kind living in the distant past.
The term "elf" is used to describe those intelligent, humanoid beings who can claim descent from the inhabitants of Areon, the Eld. In the past, the Eld entered this world as conquerors. Their dominion was largely unchallenged for millennia, the first -- and perhaps only -- successful rebellion against their rule was led by the Hyperborean barbarians known as the Thulians. The Eldritch nobility retreated en masse back to the Red Planet in the face of the Thulian onslaught. Those Eld unable to return whence they came, in time, to be known as elves.
Though elves are, on average, shorter than Men, they display a wide diversity of sizes, which is in contrast to their Eldritch forebears, who are almost all small of stature. Physically, they are lithe and agile and tend to possess fair complexions and hair. Their faces are delicate and finely chiseled -- not unattractive by any means but nevertheless possessing an "alien" quality to them that many Men find disconcerting rather than alluring. Elven ears are slightly pointed.
The alien quality of elves is not limited to their appearance. Distant and haughty, they do not seem to possess emotions as Men do or, if they do, they are far less demonstrative about them. Because of their long lives -- immortal unless some mishap befalls them or they commit suicide out of boredom -- they are often slow to act, preferring to take weeks or even months to commit themselves to a course of action of any significance. Elves gently mock humans and even dwarves as "ephemerals," seeing them as impetuous and foolhardy children. Needless to say, this has not helped their reputation among Men, many of whom consider them little better than the Eld of old.
Like Men, Elves exist in two genders but they do not form pair bonds, let alone marry. Affection, love, and even lust appear to be unknown to them, despite tall tales and folk stories that tell of star-crossed romances between humans and elves. Consequently, there are no children among the elves, leading some to believe that they are a dying race unable to procreate. If this is so, one wonders how it is that their numbers have not dwindled to non-existence in the face of human prejudice in the years since the overthrow of the Eldritch Empire. It's popularly believed that elves kidnap human children and, through magic, make them their own, a belief that has done little to improve the lot of the race.
Elves are inherently magical. All members of the race possess the ability to cast spells, though their command of sorcery seems to be more limited than that of humans. This is true, even among the Eld, which likely explains why they have turned to demons to augment their power, a practice that, while uncommon, is not wholly unknown among the elves.
A minority of sages claim that many elven sites and structures are in fact older than those of Eldritch manufacture, arguing that it was not the elves who sprang from the Eld but the reverse. For their part, the elves have nothing to say on this matter, preferring to say as little as possible about their red-skinned relations. An even smaller minority of sages suggests that the elves may in fact be the descendants of the mysterious "Ancients" whose mighty works and artifacts predate even the Eldritch Empire, citing odd similarities between Ancient devices and those produced by the elves. Once again, the elves have little to say on the matter and few Men are willing to countenance the suggestion that the Ancients were anything but members of their own kind living in the distant past.
Ares #16
Given all the recent discussion of Larry Elmore's artwork hereabouts, I was reminded of the cover he did for the Winter 1983 issue of Ares, which featured this illustration of English knights battling the alien Wersgorix from Poul Anderson's The High Crusade. This was an issue published after TSR had acquired SPI and includes a wargame (by David Cook) that re-enacts the events of Anderson's novel.Also in the issue is an original short story by Poul Anderson that serves as a sequel to The High Crusade. What a different world 1983 was! When a story an author like Poul Anderson could not only be found in the pages of a gaming magazine but whose story assumed knowledge of a prior one. Mind you, that was not at all uncommon in the gaming magazines of my youth. Dragon regularly had short fiction in its pages, often by authors as distinguished Anderson, though, as I understand it, this practice largely ceased in the years after I stopped reading it, which, if true, is a shame.
Labels:
anderson,
ares magazine,
david cook,
elmore,
memories,
nostalgia,
science fiction,
tsr,
wargames
Retrospective: Imperium

It's funny how easily subsequent events can effectively rewrite the past, at least far as our recollections go. A good case in point is GDW's Traveller, one of the classics of the Golden Age of Roleplaying and probably the most successful non-licensed SF RPG ever written. For a great many of us, especially those who didn't begin playing Traveller until after 1979, Traveller is synonymous with the Third Imperium setting, a fact that the game's own supplements hit home through their "Standards and Assumptions" text boxes that make reference to both the Imperium and its calendar system.
The reality, though, is that, at its release in 1977, Traveller had no setting except the very limited one implied by certain of its technological (limited jump drive, no FTL communications) and sociological (titled nobility) assumptions. If you look at the original printings of the Little Black Books, you'll find no references to the Imperium whatsoever. Indeed, the LBBs even imply that a large interstellar state, one ruled by an emperor, would consist of "several worlds," which seems a far cry from the 11,000 worlds of the later Third Imperium. So where did Traveller's official setting come from? I mean, aside from the works of H. Beam Piper, Poul Anderson, and Jerry Pournelle. Well, some of it comes from another game Marc Miller wrote (along with Frank Chadwick and John Harshman) and GDW published in 1977 called Imperium. Unlike Traveller, Imperium is a wargame, albeit a science fictional one. Set a couple of hundred years in our future, it presents a conflict between the Terran Confederation and an alien government called the Imperium for control of the sector of the galaxy in the neighborhood of Earth.
As presented in the wargame, the Imperium is old and technologically advanced but also conservative and slow-moving compared to the Terrans. Though evocative in itself, this setup is also useful in providing some game balance between the Imperial and Terran players. The Imperial player, as it turns out, takes the role not of the far-off emperor but of a local provincial governor taxed with bringing order to what the Imperium considers a backwater sector of space. The Terran Confederation, then, is little more than a rabble of barbarians in Imperial eyes. Victory in the game is determined by the accumulation of "glory points" and the Imperial player loses glory points if he appeals to the emperor or otherwise relies upon resources other than those immediately available to him. The Terran player, though outnumbered, need not worry about saving face at a distant imperial court and so accumulates glory points largely through straightforward conquests. Consequently, each side in Imperium has a distinct feel to it, with the Imperial player clearly having the more challenging task.
By the time I'd encountered Imperium, I'd already been playing Traveller for some time and so recognized in it the prehistory of the official GDW setting. The vaguely alien Imperium of the wargame was the "First Imperium" of the Vilani, whose defeat by the Terran Confederation set into motion a series of historical events that would eventually culminate in the Third Imperium of Traveller. But in 1977, such recognition would have been impossible and Imperium was simply a stand-alone science fiction wargame. It was only later that GDW would plunder its backstory to provide details for their proprietary Traveller setting and change the tenor of its SF RPG forever.
I should note that, as a wargame, Imperium is quite fun, though, as I noted, the Imperial player has a much more challenging task ahead of him than does the Terran player. Players who favor aggression will find that that approach doesn't often work well if you're the Imperium. Instead, it's often better to bide your time, accepting tactical losses against the Terrans -- sometimes losing entire wars -- in order to put yourself in a better position in the long term. Of course, even this approach is risky, since the game also includes random events that affect the Imperial player, reflecting the vagaries of court politics. If one is lucky, a new emperor may come to the throne who is willing to take the Terran threat seriously, but, if one is not, you may find yourself in an even worse position than before. For that reason, Imperium has a very uneven feel to it, but that's by design. It's not what one would call a "fair" wargame and one's enjoyment depends in large part on whether or not this fact bothers you.
Labels:
gdw,
miller,
retrospective,
science fiction,
traveller,
wargames
Tuesday, April 5, 2011
Ability Score Handicapping
The random generation of ability scores seems to be one of those fault lines that divides even the old school gaming community, with plenty of people willing to argue its rightness or wrongness, as I recently discovered. And it's an old and active fault line, probably going all the way back to the dawn of the hobby, when someone decided he really wanted to play a magic-user and complained bitterly to his referee when he rolled a 5 for his character's Intelligence score.
By the early 1980s, there seemed to be two "solutions" for this "problem." The first, pioneered by Superhero 2044, was a point-buy system that abandoned randomness entirely. This is the mechanical birth of character creation rather than generation. The second solution is to "handicap" rolls for ability scores in order to give PCs an edge. Take, for example, this table from FGU's Space Opera, first published in 1980:
Ability scores in Space Opera (called "personal characteristics") range from 1 to 19, but, rather than generating them by rolling 3D6 (or even 1D20) with modifiers, they're generated by rolling D100 and consulting a chart that, in the words of its designers, is "'loaded' toward the higher end of the scale." That is, even a middling roll is likely to (in most cases) give a personal characteristic score of 13 or thereabouts, ensuring that PCs are generally well above average -- and that's not even counting the dice modifiers each class gets in order to boost the characteristics most closely associated with them.
TSR's own SF RPG, Star Frontiers, opted for a similar approach to generating ability scores, although, unlike Space Opera, it not only ensures that PCs are well above average but that they are not typically too far above average:
Other TSR games also attempted to blunt the edge of random ability score generation, but did so in a different fashion, as did 1980's Top Secret:
Instead of wholly divorcing the percentile roll from the ability score generated as both Space Opera and Star Frontiers do, Top Secret instead provides a sliding scale of bonuses to the roll, so that very poor rolls are given a large boost and better rolls are given a smaller one (if any at all). This is the same approach taken in 1982's Gangbusters. In fact, it's the exact same table.
I've begun to wonder if perhaps elements of these tables couldn't be adopted in Dungeons & Dragons, at least in AD&D, where ability scores matter a great deal more than they do in OD&D. What I like about these tables is that they still preserve varying degrees of randomness rather than out and out making PCs simply better than average, as do the more ridiculous methods presented in Unearthed Arcana and even the DMG.
By the early 1980s, there seemed to be two "solutions" for this "problem." The first, pioneered by Superhero 2044, was a point-buy system that abandoned randomness entirely. This is the mechanical birth of character creation rather than generation. The second solution is to "handicap" rolls for ability scores in order to give PCs an edge. Take, for example, this table from FGU's Space Opera, first published in 1980:
Ability scores in Space Opera (called "personal characteristics") range from 1 to 19, but, rather than generating them by rolling 3D6 (or even 1D20) with modifiers, they're generated by rolling D100 and consulting a chart that, in the words of its designers, is "'loaded' toward the higher end of the scale." That is, even a middling roll is likely to (in most cases) give a personal characteristic score of 13 or thereabouts, ensuring that PCs are generally well above average -- and that's not even counting the dice modifiers each class gets in order to boost the characteristics most closely associated with them.
TSR's own SF RPG, Star Frontiers, opted for a similar approach to generating ability scores, although, unlike Space Opera, it not only ensures that PCs are well above average but that they are not typically too far above average:
Other TSR games also attempted to blunt the edge of random ability score generation, but did so in a different fashion, as did 1980's Top Secret:
Instead of wholly divorcing the percentile roll from the ability score generated as both Space Opera and Star Frontiers do, Top Secret instead provides a sliding scale of bonuses to the roll, so that very poor rolls are given a large boost and better rolls are given a smaller one (if any at all). This is the same approach taken in 1982's Gangbusters. In fact, it's the exact same table.
I've begun to wonder if perhaps elements of these tables couldn't be adopted in Dungeons & Dragons, at least in AD&D, where ability scores matter a great deal more than they do in OD&D. What I like about these tables is that they still preserve varying degrees of randomness rather than out and out making PCs simply better than average, as do the more ridiculous methods presented in Unearthed Arcana and even the DMG.
Labels:
ability scores,
musings,
old school,
other games,
tsr
For the Love of Counters
![]() |
| Counter Sheet from GDW's Snapshot |
My friends and I didn't always use the counters and maps when we played these game but we did so frequently enough that, whenever I think of them, my memories include pushing little pieces of cardboard across a poster-sized map. What's interesting is that, to a lot of people involved in the old school renaissance nowadays, this is anathema, much like the use of miniatures and dungeon tiles/floor plans. Back then, though, we never gave it a second thought, since not only was this the way these games were "supposed" to be played -- otherwise, why else did the games include these components? -- but that's how we saw them and, indeed, many other RPGs being played.
![]() |
| Counter Sheet from Star Frontiers |
I bring this up not just as a trip down memory lane, though I won't deny there's some of that at work in this post. I mention it as a mild corrective to the notions many of us have about the place and utility of miniatures and other similar representations in RPGs. I suspect there's some degree of contrariness at work here, since, in recent years, the use of miniatures has come to be associated with the post-TSR editions of Dungeons & Dragons and in a decidedly negative way. I think that's too bad, if only because I think it further divorces current discussions of old school gaming from part of how these games were played in the past.
![]() |
| Counter Sheet from Universe |
D is for Demon
"Demon" is a term used to describe a wide variety of intelligent, Chaotic beings native to the otherworldly dimension generally called "the Void" or "the Abyss." Unlike most other beings, who are believed by Men to have been created by one or more gods, demons have no such divine origin, although their exact relationship to the gods and to Creation itself is a matter of debate among sages and priests. One popular theory holds that demons are spontaneously generated by Chaos itself, while another suggests that demons are the inadvertent consequence of the gods' attempts to bring order out of Chaos. For their part, demons explicitly deny both such theories, for they also deny the existence of the gods themselves, claiming them to be merely the fancies of Men.Regardless of the truth, demons are potent agents of Chaos, possessing a wide range of powers and abilities, from the lowliest dretch to the mightiest lord. Despite this, no demon can enter the material world unbidden, which is why they rely heavily on a network of cults and secret societies to provide them with the means to do so. Demons are renowned deal-makers, offering mortal beings power in exchange for service. Of course, some mortals, most notably the Eld, believe themselves superior to demons and dare to employ dark sorceries to command rather than serve them. Though possible, such a path is risky and many a would-be black magician found himself destroyed rather than aggrandized by his actions.
Demons amid no hierarchy among their own kind except that of power. Greater demons rule over lesser types through strength alone, with even more powerful demons -- called variously "lords" or "princes" -- ruling over them all. A few of the most well-known and influential of these demon lords are the following:
- Furfur: Lord of Secrets
- Orcus: Lord of the Undead
- Tsath-Dagon: Lord of Aquatic and Amphibian Beings
- Yan-Gant-Y-Tan: Lord of Thieves
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






