Tuesday, July 1, 2025

Whither Grognardia? (Part II)

It’s been almost five years since I brought Grognardia back from its extended hiatus and, in that time, I’ve worked hard to stay true to its original spirit as a space for reflection, commentary, and celebration of the history and legacy of roleplaying games, especially those we now call “old school.” That guiding purpose hasn’t changed and it won’t. However, after more than a year of mulling over how best to balance this blog with my ongoing RPG design work, I’ve come to a decision, one that affects how I’ll be handling Grognardia from now on, as well as the future of the two games that have increasingly claimed my creative attention: Thousand Suns and Secrets of sha-Arthan.

Starting today, I’ll be moving all my RPG design work – new rules, setting development, playtest notes, and related commentary – to a separate Substack newsletter. This will be the new home for all things related to my ongoing RPG design projects. My reasons for doing this are partly practical and partly experimental. Substack offers tools for managing subscribers, tracking readership, and organizing content, tools Blogger doesn’t provide but that are increasingly important to me, especially as I prepare to release material for both games commercially.

Like Grognardia, the newsletter is entirely free to read. There’s no paywall, no locked posts, just another outlet where I can share ideas and progress, hopefully in a more focused and consistent fashion. That said, I do maintain a small Patreon, which I plan to continue for the foreseeable future. It doesn’t generate much income, but I’m immensely grateful to the readers who’ve chosen to support me there over the years. Their generosity has helped me fund art and other resources for Secrets of sha-Arthan and related projects, expenses that would otherwise come entirely out of pocket. I don’t expect anyone to become a patron, but I do genuinely appreciate those of you who do. It makes a real difference.

Just as important, splitting these projects off to their own platform will help me stay focused. Right now, things are more scattered than I’d like. I often find myself juggling work across multiple trains of thought, which I suspect has hindered my ability to make as much progress on either Thousand Suns or Secrets of sha-Arthan as I would have liked. I’m hopeful that this change will help bring some order to the chaos and allow me to be more productive overall.

That said, Grognardia isn't going anywhere. The blog will continue much as it has since its return, with daily posts (more or less), musings on the history of the hobby, looks at old gaming materials, and the occasional detour into obscure corners of pulp literature or genre films. If that’s why you’re here, nothing will change. If you're interested in my RPG design work, I hope you'll also subscribe to the Substack, where I’ll be posting a couple of times a week – one update each for Thousand Suns and Secrets of sha-Arthan (perhaps more, but I don't want to be overly ambitious just yet). 

This division of labor is an experiment, like much of what I do. If it works, I hope it’ll benefit not only me but you, the readers, by giving each project the attention and clarity it deserves.

13 comments:

  1. Whew! Grognardia is a standard bearer for many of us, a fun place to hang out and chew over all sorts of fat and gristle. May your new Substack project blossom in the same way!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I've never made a Substack account, but now I'm going to do one because I'm really interested in yours!

    Good luck with your next adventure and I'll see you in both places!

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's good that your experimenting with new tools.

    One fear I have is that Google is not really supporting Blogger/Blogspot as much as they used to, and one day they may just decide to pull the plug and get rid of the existing ones. Google has killed a lot of products that no longer serve their purposes, and a lot of dedicated bloggers moved to having their own domains and Wordpress services.

    I hope you have luck with Substack.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Blogger is definitely in a bad place right now. Its analytics tools have always been terrible, but they're quite subpar in comparison to those of almost every other platform, which makes it hard for me to determine just how popular any given post actually is and with whom.

      Delete
    2. The way Google used to work (I don't know if they changed or not to be honest) is that results were ranked by how many others linked to a post (with folks that paid add revenue added on top). Every blog that had a blogroll reenforced each other and helped the rankings. When everyone moved over to different platforms that was mostly torn down and has yet to be properly rebuilt (and might not ever be rebuilt).

      Delete
    3. That Google might pull the plug out has worried me a bit too. Is Grognardia backed-up on the Internet Archive or similar?

      Delete
    4. Jacob72,

      I download it every so often, just in case. Whether it's preserved anywhere else is something I don't know.

      Delete
    5. I've just checked, and archive.org has quite a few snapshots. archive.is has one too, but it's eleven years old; I've taken the liberty of putting in a request for an update.

      Delete
  4. Jim Hodges---
    I am so glad this blog is staying around! Good luck with your new venture as well.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am glad this blog is not going anyplace.

    Somewhat off topic, but since the title is "Whither Grognardia?", do you still plan to discuss more EPT given this is its 50th anniversary, and are you going to continue the recent series of Traveller posts? The latter has resparked my interest in the game, one of the few from which I collected a lot of material back in the day.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi James have you ever collected all of your blog posts and published them on something like drivethrurpg? I'd be very interested to read them in book format

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's something I have in fact considered several times, but it'd be a big undertaking, since there are almost 5000 posts to sift through. That said, enough people have asked me about it that I should seriously look into it again.

      Delete
  7. Different function, different form, different forum, different focus. And yes, Blogger is really tired.

    ReplyDelete